Montego Bay, Montego Bay, Jamaica
resort comparison guide

Riu Reggae vs Toby's Resort

Choosing between Hotel Riu Reggae and Toby’s Resort? This in-depth comparison breaks down location, vibe, rooms, food, nightlife, price & more so you can decide which stay is the best fit for your next Montego Bay getaway.

Hotel Riu Reggae resort
Hotel Riu Reggae
Adults-Only • Mahoe Bay Beach • All-Inclusive

Best for adults who want a beachfront, adults-only all-inclusive in Montego Bay with pools, included dining, drinks, activities, and an easy airport-area location.

Toby's Resort resort
Toby's Resort
Casual Hotel • Montego Bay • Independent Stay

Better for travelers who want a simpler, casual Montego Bay hotel stay with a more independent feel and less of a full-resort, all-inclusive structure.

Quick Verdict: Hotel Riu Reggae vs Toby's Resort

If you want an adults-only, beachfront all-inclusive with multiple pools, themed dining, bars, entertainment, and non-motorized water sports included, Hotel Riu Reggae is the stronger vacation-resort pick.

If your priority is a lower-key Montego Bay base where you can keep the stay simpler and spend more time out and about, Toby's Resort is the more casual alternative.

Bottom line: choose Hotel Riu Reggae for a full adults-only all-inclusive beach resort experience; choose Toby's Resort for a simpler hotel-style stay in Montego Bay.

Hotel Riu Reggae vs Toby's Resort – At a Glance

Category Hotel Riu Reggae Toby's Resort
Overall Vibe Adults-only, all-inclusive beachfront resort with a lively pool scene, multiple bars, organized activities, and a polished resort setup. Casual Montego Bay hotel with a simpler, more independent feel and fewer built-in resort extras.
Location On Mahoe Bay beach in Montego Bay, about 2.7 km from Sangster International Airport, with a short transfer time. In Montego Bay, better suited to travelers who want a straightforward hotel base rather than a beachfront all-inclusive resort setting.
Rooms & Suites 454-room adults-only resort setup with standard resort comforts and easy access to dining, pools, beach, and activities. More traditional hotel-style accommodations, best for travelers who do not need a large all-inclusive resort environment.
Dining Five restaurants total: a main buffet, Asian, Italian, Caribbean-fusion Kulinarium, and Steakhouse, plus poolside quick bites and a beach jerk station. A simpler dining approach; better if you plan to keep meals flexible and explore Montego Bay beyond the hotel.
Pools & Beach Three outdoor pools, including infinity pools and two swim-up bars, plus a beachfront Mahoe Bay setting. More modest pool-and-hotel atmosphere, without the same beachfront all-inclusive resort scale.
Activities & Atmosphere Adults-only setting with included activities such as beach volleyball, kayaking, snorkel gear, stand-up paddle surfing, pedaloes, and a pool scuba tryout. Better for a simple, come-and-go stay where the hotel is a base rather than the center of the trip.
Price & Value Best value for adults who will use the all-inclusive dining, drinks, pools, beach access, activities, and entertainment. Best value for travelers who prefer a more basic hotel stay and do not need meals, drinks, and resort programming bundled in.

Rooms & Suites: Adults-Only Resort Comfort vs Casual Hotel Simplicity

Hotel Riu Reggae – Room Style

Rooms at Hotel Riu Reggae fit an adults-only, all-inclusive resort stay where the appeal is as much about the beach, pools, restaurants, and bars as the room itself.

  • 454-room beachfront resort layout in Montego Bay
  • Best for adults who want resort convenience close to the beach and pools
  • All-inclusive setup with meals, drinks, activities, entertainment, and WiFi included

Hotel Riu Reggae is the better pick if you want the room to be part of a larger adults-only resort experience with everything close at hand.

Toby's Resort – Room Style

Toby's Resort is the more straightforward option, with a casual hotel feel instead of a large all-inclusive beachfront resort format.

  • Traditional hotel-style stay rather than an all-inclusive resort package
  • Better if you plan to be out exploring rather than staying on property all day
  • Best for travelers who value simplicity over resort scale

If you want a no-fuss Montego Bay base and do not need bundled resort amenities, Toby's Resort is the more practical fit.

Dining & Drinks: Full All-Inclusive Variety vs Flexible Simplicity

Hotel Riu Reggae – Restaurants & Bars

Dining at Hotel Riu Reggae is a major part of the all-inclusive appeal, with a main buffet, multiple specialty restaurants, poolside bites, a jerk station, and bars built into the resort experience.

Expect:

  • Ackee buffet with international dishes and live cooking stations
  • Specialty options including Asian, Italian, Caribbean-fusion Kulinarium, and Steakhouse
  • Bars including swim-up options and a 24-hour lobby bar setup

Toby's Resort – Restaurants & Bars

Toby's Resort is better approached as a simpler hotel stay where dining is less about an all-inclusive circuit and more about keeping plans flexible.

  • Better for travelers who do not need every meal and drink bundled
  • Good fit if you want to try local dining around Montego Bay
  • Less suited to travelers who want a full resort restaurant lineup on site

If dining variety, bars, and included drinks matter most, Hotel Riu Reggae is the clear winner.

Pools & Beach: Beachfront All-Inclusive Scene vs Modest Hotel Base

Hotel Riu Reggae – Pool & Beach Scene

Hotel Riu Reggae has the stronger pool-and-beach setup, with three outdoor pools, infinity-pool features, swim-up bars, loungers, umbrellas, and direct Mahoe Bay beach access.

  • Three outdoor pools including infinity pools
  • Two swim-up bars for a social daytime pool scene
  • Beachfront location on Mahoe Bay in Montego Bay

Toby's Resort – Pool & Beach Scene

Toby's Resort is more modest by comparison, best for travelers who want a hotel base rather than a full beachfront pool-and-beach resort experience.

  • More casual hotel atmosphere
  • Better if you do not need a large all-inclusive pool scene
  • Less focused on bundled beach, bar, and activity programming

If you want the beach and pools to be the center of the trip, Hotel Riu Reggae is the better choice.

Activities & Atmosphere: Adults-Only All-Inclusive Energy vs Independent Montego Bay Stay

Hotel Riu Reggae – Activities & Atmosphere

Hotel Riu Reggae is designed for adults who want a contained resort experience with included activities, daytime pool energy, evening entertainment, and wellness options.

  • Included non-motorized water activities such as kayaking, snorkel gear, paddle surfing, and pedaloes
  • Fitness center, group fitness classes, and wellness facilities available
  • Adults-only atmosphere with all guests 18 and older

Toby's Resort – Activities & Atmosphere

Toby's Resort is the quieter, more independent choice, better for travelers who prefer using the hotel as a base instead of relying on a built-in resort schedule.

  • More relaxed, casual-hotel pace
  • Better for guests who want to plan their own days around Montego Bay
  • Less emphasis on all-inclusive entertainment and activity programming

If you want activities, drinks, dining, and entertainment bundled into the stay, Hotel Riu Reggae is the stronger fit.

Price & Value: Which Montego Bay Stay Feels More Worth It?

Hotel Riu Reggae – Value Snapshot

Hotel Riu Reggae offers the most value when you plan to stay on property and use the all-inclusive inclusions: meals, drinks, pools, beach, activities, entertainment, WiFi, and wellness facilities.

  • Best for adults who want an all-inclusive beach vacation
  • Great if you will use the restaurants, bars, pools, and included activities
  • Strong value for travelers who want resort convenience close to the airport

Toby's Resort – Value Snapshot

Toby's Resort is the better value if you want a simpler Montego Bay hotel stay and do not need the cost or structure of an all-inclusive beachfront resort.

  • Best for travelers who want a practical hotel base
  • Stronger if you plan to dine and explore off property
  • Worth it if resort extras are not your main priority

Who Wins? Best Montego Bay Hotel by Travel Style

Best for Adults-Only All-Inclusive
Hotel Riu Reggae resort

Hotel Riu Reggae

Choose Hotel Riu Reggae if you want an adults-only, beachfront, all-inclusive resort with multiple pools, swim-up bars, specialty dining, activities, and entertainment included.

Best for Simple Montego Bay Base
Toby's Resort resort

Toby's Resort

Toby's Resort is the better pick if you want a casual Montego Bay hotel base and prefer a simpler stay over a bundled all-inclusive resort experience.

Best for Pools, Beach & Included Drinks
Hotel Riu Reggae resort

Hotel Riu Reggae

For adults who want the vacation to revolve around the beach, pools, bars, and included dining, Hotel Riu Reggae is the more complete resort choice.

Best for Flexible, Low-Key Stays
Toby's Resort resort

Toby's Resort

If you want fewer resort commitments and more flexibility to shape your own Montego Bay trip, Toby's Resort makes more sense.

BOOK YOUR STAY NOW

Questions? Contact Us!

Hotel Riu Reggae

BOOK YOUR STAY NOW

Questions? Contact Us!

Close